What Should You Do If You Need Your Cards Back Sooner Than 65 Days From PSA? Premium Podcast: April 11, 2025
This episode is for premium membersJoin · watch it nowAlready a member? Log in
Premium Pod · 4-10-2025 In this episode of The Premium Pod, we help premium members make money flipping sports cards. We answer these questions and more... Today we're going to touch on questions from: Gregory Geoffrey Trevor Brian Eli Mason Dan P Brad Paul…
Questions answered on this episode · 7
—We answer these questions and more...
—Today we're going to touch on questions from:
—I have been offered a trade. This Arch Manning for my 2024 Brock Purdy Downtown PSA 9. The Purdy comps around $425 with obvious upside and liquidity, but I have really been trying to get into some Arch Manning, and haven't been able to find the right deal.
••:••Thinking about having you guys crack this and re submit to psa for a card and auto grade. Have you made this play before and is it the right play for what looks like a card that could grade well? This is a 2020 select silver concourse Montana on card auto.
••:••I bought this Prizm DP Arch Manning silver online using pics from a seller that made it seem like it was well centered enough to gem. However viewing it in person, there's no way the card will get better than a PSA 9 based on the top to bottom centering. Currently, I only see one PSA 9 sale of this card from late February for $120. According to gemrate there's only 1 graded PSA 10 graded so far. Should I try and grade mine hoping that a 9 will still sell for north of $100 by the time I get it back from PSA, or just try and sell it raw?
••:••What is y'all's take on high end or even mid-tier product veteran and retired/HOF cards? Not the GOATS, but top 100 all-time and even borderline top-5. Basically, the guys that are in high demand and sell well, but come out in these products every year.
••:••What cards should I be holding in general? My dad and I have a little side business selling on eBay and Whatnot and our mission is not to immediately put money in our pockets, but reinvest all $ into building a million dollar PC. We recently bought a PSA 10 Topps Chrome Lebron rookie and I know the obvious cards, but out of the modern products, which cards are holds?
Timestamps, the plays of the week and the transcript are inside.Unlock this episode · joinOnly a few available spots at any given time
Members also get
Ask Paul anythingAnswered by Paul within two business days. The best questions go on the monthly Pod, with an email that jumps you to the timestamp.See it → Paul’s plays of the weekPinned in the Rankings with target cost and the lane: Raw to Grade, Regrade, Already Graded.See it → Searchable archiveEvery question ever asked, 215 episodes back. Search “upcharge” and jump to the answer.See it →
Free this week · Sports Card Strategy Show
Sports Card Strategy Show
November 16, 2026 · Card Collecting and Investing
Mendoza Is QB1: Sell Now? + Where the Same Slab Sells for 84% More
Watch / Listen / Read →
Sports Card Strategy Show
November 9, 2026 · Card Collecting and Investing
Card Sales Up 174%: State of the Hobby + Wemby Cards That Gem 84%
Watch / Listen / Read →
Sports Card Strategy Show
November 2, 2026 · Card Collecting and Investing
PSA Value Is Back ($39.99) + We Rebuilt NoOffseason.com: All New! The Best Value In The Hobby!
Watch / Listen / Read →